Value: 15%
A gentle reminder that as with all LRNT courses, you are expected to incorporate APA standards for citations, formatting, and references and to back up your writing with evidence and appropriate academic literature as necessary. You are required to pay attention to grammar and clarity and to avoid colloquialisms. References are not included in the assignment word count. Also, don’t forget the numerous resources available to you as you build your competence and fluency with APA formatting and writing style. In particular, check out the RRU APA 7 formatting checklists and RRU WriteAnswers, which allow you to ask your APA questions.
Purpose
The purpose of this assignment is to deepen your understanding of instructional design models by critically comparing at least two models and communicating your learning through multiple forms of scholarly communication. You will synthesize your understanding by creating a visual or organizational artifact, sharing it through an academic blog with a brief written reflection, and presenting a concise oral synthesis to your learning community. This assignment provides flexibility in how you demonstrate your learning while ensuring all students meet the same learning outcomes.
Deliverables
There is one deliverable for this assignment:
- A comparative representation that accompanies an academic blog post, including a 300-word reflection.
Deliverable (1) Comparative representation and academic reflection (Blog)
You will investigate and compare at least two instructional design (ID) models and communicate your analysis through a visual or organizational artifact. Publish your comparative representation on your course blog and accompany it with a 300-word academic reflection (APA 7) that provides context for your analysis and learning. Consider the audience that would benefit most from your comparative analysis (e.g., educators, trainers, instructional designers, or educational leaders), and write accordingly.
Your reflection should situate your comparative representation and communicate the significance of your learning. You may wish to address questions such as:
- What instructional design models did you compare, and why did you choose them?
- What were the most significant similarities and differences you identified?
- What insights emerged through your comparison?
- How might these insights inform your future instructional design practice?
- Why did you select this format to communicate your analysis?
You have flexibility in how you represent your comparative analysis. Choose a format that best communicates your understanding and supports your intended message.
Provided are examples of possible formats. This list is not exhaustive, and you are welcome to propose an alternative format in consultation with the instructor:
| Format | To demonstrate |
| Comparison Matrix or Table | Detailed comparison across several criteria (e.g., assumptions, strengths, weaknesses, contexts) |
| Concept Map | Relationships between ID models and concepts |
| Decision Tree | Helping an instructional designer (or trainer, educator, other context) to determine when each model is most appropriate |
| Journey Map | Mapping the learner or designer experience through each model |
| Mind Map | Branching ideas and characteristics from a central theme |
| Timeline | Historical development and evolution of instructional design models |
| Venn Diagram | Similarities and differences |
Submission
Deliverable: Comparative Representation and Reflection [Blog post]
Submit a link to your published blog post and any addenda, including your AI use disclaimer, in the Assignment 1 Moodle Dropbox by the assignment deadline.
Generative AI
Currently, generative AI invents scholars, institutional affiliations, and citations with considerable confidence. Remember, “the appearance of confidence is not proof of accuracy” (Dingle, 2026). If you use an AI when working on this assignment, you are bound by the RRU guidelines on AI use, which are built on the assumption that students will behave ethically and comply with the University Policy on Academic Integrity and Misconduct.
You are expected to submit an AI Use Declaration as an addendum to your submission in the Moodle Assignment 1 Dropbox. This declaration is separate from the assignment word count and should provide a transparent account of how AI contributed to both your process and your submitted work.
Briefly identify the AI tool(s) you used and describe how you used them. This might include uses such as brainstorming, exploring ideas, organizing or refining your comparison, supporting the development of your comparative representation, or editing for clarity, grammar, or accessibility. Explain how you reviewed, verified, adapted, or made decisions about AI-generated content and how you ensured that the analysis, interpretation, and final work remained your own intellectual contribution.
Conclude with a short reflection on your use of AI. You might consider: What did AI afford or make possible? What did it limit? How, if at all, did it influence your thinking or design decisions? What concerns or questions arose, and how did you respond?
If you did not use generative AI in completing the assignment, simply state this in your AI Use Declaration and then conclude with a short reflection on what influenced your decision not to use it.
Grading
This assignment will be marked according to the following rubric:
| Criteria | Exemplary (A+ to A) | Proficient (A− to B+) | Developing (B to B−) | Insufficient (F) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Comparative Representation | Creates a purposeful, insightful comparative representation that demonstrates strong synthesis of at least two instructional design models. Clearly communicates key characteristics, similarities, differences, and appropriate contexts for application. The representation is well-organized, engaging, and effectively uses the chosen format to communicate understanding. | Creates a clear, well-organized comparative representation that demonstrates thoughtful synthesis of at least two instructional design models. Accurately communicates key characteristics, similarities, differences, and contexts for application, with minor areas for further development. | Creates a representation that demonstrates a primarily descriptive or limited comparison of instructional design models. Key characteristics, similarities, differences, or contexts for application require further development. Organization or communication of ideas may lack clarity. | The representation does not adequately demonstrate understanding or comparison of at least two instructional design models. Key characteristics, similarities, differences, or contexts for application are missing, substantially inaccurate, or insufficiently developed. |
| 300-Word Academic Reflection | Provides a thoughtful, critically reflective academic discussion that effectively contextualizes the comparative representation, explains key insights and learning, and makes meaningful connections to instructional design practice. Writing is clear, concise, and scholarly, with accurate APA 7 conventions. | Provides a clear academic reflection that contextualizes the representation, identifies key learning, and makes relevant connections to instructional design practice. Writing is organized and demonstrates effective scholarly communication, with minor APA 7 or writing issues. | Provides a reflection that is primarily descriptive, with limited consideration of key learning or application to instructional design practice. Connections to the representation may be unclear or underdeveloped. Scholarly writing, organization, or APA 7 conventions require improvement. | The reflection is missing, substantially incomplete, or does not adequately contextualize the representation or demonstrate meaningful reflection on learning and instructional design practice. Scholarly communication and APA 7 conventions are insufficiently demonstrated. |
